Mahoning Valley Forum

Youngstown & The Mahoning Valley => Youngstown in General => Topic started by: Towntalk on September 08, 2012, 01:40:24 AM

Title: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Towntalk on September 08, 2012, 01:40:24 AM
For the past 35 years group after group has been started up to discuss Youngstown's future (1977-2012), and have absolutely nothing to show for it. A very small handful of groups were organized that have shown progress, but unlike their counterparts, after the talks, there was action, and there has been progress that we can see with our own two eyes.

Today Youngstown is becoming a center for the high tech industry, and the energy companies are opening even more doors for good paying jobs with a future, but these facts seem to escape those who simply sit around dreaming dreams that can never be fulfilled.

We can all agree that quality of life is important to any community, but without good paying jobs it is meaningless. The arts can never provide hundreds of high paying jobs that can allow families the upward mobility required for a strong vibrant community.

While we can and should support the arts, we must keep it in its proper perspective  and not ignore the real life opportunities that are starting to come our way.

We want and need opportunities where families can have financial stability ... be able to buy a home ... send their children to decent schools ... and have hope for the future, for only when this is achieved can they support the arts.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: irishbobcat on September 08, 2012, 07:47:39 AM
I can ignore the real opportunities if they include a fracking process that pumps millions of gallons of toxic chemicals into our
ground that will make our land and water useless for future generations....

When the water and land are poisoned, who will buy a home here, send their kids to school here, and have any hope for a future?

Why do conservative-minded folks love to blame and bash the arts for Youngstown's current woes?
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Youngstownshrimp on September 08, 2012, 08:06:47 AM
One merely has to read the archives here of my posts on Youngstown's future and see some of us as with you, have pounded the same subject.  In a way it is sweet "I told you so" on what is happening today in Youngstown concerning the energy boom.  It is real and reality as we speak, this is just the beginning, Youngstown is wealthy again with the new found wealth eminating from the ground and not as the innovative steel industry of yesterday.  It is not because of the hipsters, occupiers and community organizers, there fifteen minutes of fame has passed.  Rejoice as educated innovators and producers from all over the US are and will be decending onto the Mahoning Valley.  Will there be missteps and mistakes along the way, sure.  But rest assured, business is booming in the energy sector.  The old socialist bent guard of the Valley cannot stand up to free enterprise and the billions already invested in our lands.
Another prediction will be the withering away of the entitled leaders, notice the silence.  Soon new names will appear and unlike  most of the US which have not been blessed with energy-will rise to the top.  They will be creating opportunities and jobs, the majority conservative democrats and republicans will be the new leaders.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: irishbobcat on September 08, 2012, 08:36:13 AM
The problems with the mistakes and missteps that will occur is that they will poison our land and water with toxic chemicals, Ron.
Is Youngstown really wealthy again? I drive across town from the east side to the west side daily for work....don't see the wealth in the sections
of town I drive through......

I think Youngstown's new wealth is resting on the top floor of the some fracking CEO's office out of town and out of state.....
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Towntalk on September 08, 2012, 10:29:53 AM
The industries of Youngstown's past didn't come about over night ... it took time, and a great Civil War before the steel mills started to take off. Prior to that Youngstown was a sleepy village with coal mining as its main industry.

It will take time for these new industries to really blossem, but even now, one of them is internationally known (Turning Point Technology). It's not as big as Apple or HP, both of which started in family garages by the way, or Microsoft, but it is steady growth and that is important.

As to the blighted areas of the city. unfortunately those will continue to be with us for some time to come, for they are too wide spread to be eleminated over night.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Towntalk on September 08, 2012, 11:29:43 AM
From the very outset, the rest of the state looked down their collective noses at Youngstown, and would gladly have seen it disappear, but it didn't and to the contrary, it continued its growth until it was one of the wealthiest cities in the Midwest in 1910.

In point of fact, nothing has ever been easy for Youngstown, and had it not been for a group of harder than nails men, it still would be a small village.

With spines of steel, a small group of men built this city, defying all the naysayers, and they didn't do it by sitting around flapping their gums about unattainable goals.

Today some folks condemn the sort of men who built Youngstown. We hear them lambasted at political campaign rallies, yet there was a time when the political animals came crawling into Youngstown pleading for their support.

Oh to be sure, these men put their money where their mouths were.

One man in particular was so tough that when a gang of hoodlums tried to stop him from laying tracks for his railroad he personally stood an armed man down who threatened to kill him, causing the man's friends to run away in fear.

The man I speak of had humble beginnings. He was far from rich. He worked in his fathers hotel, yet rose out of poverty to become one of the wealthiest men in the state, and when he died, great leaders from around the country came to his funeral by the rail cars full.

That man was Chauncey Andrews.

This city needs more of this type of man than we do dreamers who lack the intestinal fortitude of the Andrews', the Tod's, the Wicks, and all the other great leaders this city has had in her past.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: iwasthere on September 08, 2012, 04:58:09 PM
i read all the posts in this section. everyone has valid pts in making ytown and its propers grt again. gas and oil exploration will continue way after all of us are pushing up daisies over fifty yrs plus. all industries must be given free range in the r and d areana  with common sense gvernmental over sight.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: irishbobcat on September 08, 2012, 05:08:07 PM
The Andrews',Tods', and Wicks' didn't pump toxic chemicals into our ground to make Youngstown prosper....
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Towntalk on September 08, 2012, 05:32:41 PM
Look to the polluted Mahoning River, the contaminated land on steel mill properties and the caved in coal mines my friend and tell us that.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: irishbobcat on September 08, 2012, 08:31:52 PM
Well, I guess since we have already contaminated the Mahoning River and steel mill properties we might as
well contaminate the farm lands and every other lot in a neighborhood near you and me.....
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: iwasthere on September 08, 2012, 10:29:16 PM
 heavy industry can prosper without condimating the land that is useless for the next generation by using st of the art technology that produces less pollants in the air sea and land.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Rick Rowlands on September 10, 2012, 09:54:05 PM
I don't think we give mother nature enough credit.  I have been exploring former industrial sites throughout the valley for years, and I must say that nature has a way of completely reclaiming even the nastiest polluted areas.  Right now I'm exploring Chauncy Andrews' first coal mine, located basically under Lansdowne Airport.  Although I know there were rail lines up there, two slope entrances, tipples, tailings piles etc., it is extremely difficult to find any of it.  You would never know there was a mine there except for some maps that say there was.   I've also been up to the oil fields along Oil Creek in NWPA in areas that I know once had crude oil spewing all over the place, and that too has been totally reclaimed.

I know Dennis likes to exaggerate a lot and to make his point by fearmongering, but the reality is that it is very difficult to cause lasting damage to the environment.  And that was back when nobody cared.  Today, the last thing these billion dollar companies want to do is cause environmental damage, and they take great pains to minimize their footprint and to be a good neighbor.  It would be in all of our best interests to embrace the opportunities presented by the energy boom instead of wasting energy in a fruitless attempt to stop it.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: iwasthere on September 10, 2012, 10:03:24 PM
rr that is the reason why am corp go over to china and other countries that are lax in environmental safe procedures.
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: irishbobcat on September 11, 2012, 12:01:24 AM
Ricky, in your research, when current land owners land and water goes bad because of fracking and ther property loses all its value, do the fracking companies compensate th propery owners 100  percent so they can buy a new home and property?


If they don't, this is why we can't have fracking companies in our area screwing our neighbors and poisoning our environment, like you would like them to do.....
Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: Rick Rowlands on September 11, 2012, 01:31:04 AM
First of all, such a scenario would only be valid for property that does not have city water.  If tied into the sanitary water system contaminated groundwater would be immaterial.  Secondly, the lease has a provision prohibiting the lessors from polluting groundwater.  Third, there are no proven instances of modern well drilling operations polluting groundwater, so your scenario is purely hypothetical.

Title: Re: Youngstown's Future
Post by: irishbobcat on September 11, 2012, 01:38:15 PM
And the property owners who live in rural areas without city water?

And what about well casing failures that spill toxic chemicals above ground?